Glock 19 vs Glock 45: Can They Share a Holster?

Glock 19 vs Glock 45: Can They Share a Holster?

Quick answer. For Glock 19 vs Glock 45 holster fit, start with the model in the product title. MyHolster lists the black MASC_105LP pancake holster separately for Glock 19 Gen 5 and Glock 45, using the same SKU and gallery on both pages. That gives you a documented catalog match for this one design. Choose the page that names your model and check optic clearance separately.

An unmarked leather holster tells you little about which models it was made for. They are the same length on the versions compared below. The holster still has its own shape, attachment and clearance limits. A listing that names both models, or two model-named listings for the same documented catalog item, tells you more about compatibility than a ruler or a storefront thumbnail.

One slide length, two frame sizes

Glock describes the G19 Gen5 as compact. The standard G45 pairs a compact-length slide with a full-size frame, which Glock calls a crossover. Both reference versions have a 174 mm slide and a 102 mm barrel. Glock gives the G45 a height of 139 mm with the magazine in place, compared with 128 mm for the G19 Gen5. The 11 mm difference is easiest to see at the grip end. Overall length is a separate measurement and differs by 4 mm on the two reference pages.

Published dimensions for the reference models
Measurement G19 Gen5 Standard G45
Frame Compact Full size
Slide length 174 mm 174 mm
Overall length 185 mm 189 mm
Overall width 34 mm 34 mm
Height with magazine 128 mm 139 mm

These figures apply to the two versions identified in Glock’s published technical data. Glock also released Gen6 versions of both models. Use the generation and any MOS designation from your own model paperwork before comparing a product listing. Glock G19 Gen5 specifications · Glock G45 specifications

Height with a magazine measures the whole profile. It helps explain why the grip looks different even when the slide ends line up. The holster has to fit the surfaces it encloses, especially around the trigger guard, slide and sights. Two pistols with similar published dimensions can still need separate confirmation for a particular product.

MyHolster catalog matches for the Glock 19 and 45

The table records the model wording on each product page and the available Shopify variants checked on November 21, 2026. Each row refers to the linked listing. The third and fourth rows show other attachment styles, each with its own model wording and SKU. Ask about any generation or accessory configuration the listing leaves unspecified.

Model names and available variants
Named fit and product Catalog SKU What the listing confirms
Glock 19 Gen 5 black leather pancake holster MASC_105LP Gen 5 in title. Black, right hand, two belt slots.
Glock 45 black leather pancake holster MASC_105LP Glock 45 in title. Black, right hand, two belt slots.
Glock 19 leather IWB holster 14MYH106LP_BL
14MYH106LP_BR
Glock 19 in title. Leather with a clip shown in the gallery. Confirm the generation.
Glock 45 leather OWB paddle holster MASC_EFES_HK_BL
MASC_EFES_HK_BR
Glock 45 in title. Polymer paddle. Listing excludes red-dot optics.

Why the two pancake pages look alike

The Glock 19 Gen 5 page and the Glock 45 page publish the same three image URLs and the same MASC_105LP SKU. Each page names its own compatible model. The two views below come from the shared gallery and show the shape of the leather and positions of the belt slots. The model names above the photos identify the listings. The images themselves are shared catalog photos.

Two views from the shared MASC_105LP gallery
Glock 19 Gen 5 listing Glock 45 listing
Black leather pancake holster with two belt slots, outer face Reverse of black leather pancake holster showing wings and belt slots

Keep the product URL or the order confirmation with the SKU if you need to look up the fit later. A packing label that says only MASC_105LP gives you the stock code. The link supplies the model name, handing and description that put that code in context. Fit claims here come from the product titles and SKU records.

Clip, slots or paddle

Look at the back of the holster first if the storefront lists several leather options in the same color. On the Glock 19 IWB listing, the gallery shows a single clip. IWB stands for inside the waistband. The pancake design has two slots that form part of its leather wings. The Glock 45 OWB paddle listing shows a separate polymer paddle behind the leather. OWB stands for outside the waistband. These photos show the attachment details because the front views alone can make the designs look closer than they are.

Clip side of the brown Glock 19 leather IWB holster

The Glock 45 paddle page lists a maximum belt width of 1¾ inches. That figure belongs to the paddle listing. If you need a specific belt width for the pancake or clip style, check the individual page or ask for the opening or clip measurement for the exact SKU.

Brown Glock 45 leather holster with its black polymer paddle

Check the optic language on the exact listing

MOS identifies an optic-ready pistol configuration. An installed optic has its own dimensions, so clearance depends on what the holster maker documents for that product. The Glock 45 paddle listing explicitly excludes red-dot optics. A sight channel accommodates the front sight. Look for a separate statement about clearance for the optic near the rear of the slide.

Before comparing two listings. Write down the model and generation, any MOS designation, and the name of any installed optic or rail accessory. Compare those details with the full title and fit notes. For an existing holster, have its SKU or a photo of its label ready if you ask the maker about cross-fit.

If the label on an older holster has worn off, look for an order email, a box sticker or a product code on the receipt. A photo of the accessory can help the maker identify the design, especially if it shows the attachment and any stamped marks. Once you have an exact match, follow the maker’s fit and safety instructions. Poor seating or an exposed trigger area is a reason to set the holster aside and ask about that combination.

If you contact support about two similar pages, send both links and mention which model name you expected to see. A short question about a particular SKU makes it easier to tell whether the pages describe the same catalog item or merely use similar product names. It also gives you a useful record if you check the fit again later.

Frequently asked questions

What holsters can a Glock 45 fit in?

MyHolster lists the MASC_105LP leather pancake and MASC_EFES_HK leather paddle by the Glock 45 model name. The paddle page excludes red-dot optics. Check the wording of your chosen listing if your G45 has a variant suffix or an installed accessory.

Is Glock 45 the same size as Glock 19?

The standard G45 and G19 Gen5 share a published slide length of 174 mm and an overall width of 34 mm. The G45 is taller at 139 mm with the magazine in place. Glock lists the G19 Gen5 at 128 mm.

Is the Glock 45 basically a Glock 19X?

Glock says the G45 draws on the 19X design. Both are crossover designs. For a holster order, look for the exact model name or an explicit cross-fit listing from the holster maker.

What is the Glock 45 comparable to?

In size terms, Glock describes the standard G45 as a crossover with a compact-length slide and a full-size frame. The G19 Gen5 is a useful comparison for slide length. The G17 is a useful comparison for frame size. Use the G45 designation when checking a holster listing.

Back to blog